Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective
Team up to crack Victorian crimes before Sherlock does—navigate 1890s London together, connect obscure clues, and prove you're sharper than the world's greatest detective.
2 players. 60+ min. Hard. Co-op: same team
You need: Casebook with case entries, London map, Newspapers, London Directory, Pencil and paper.
Don't have it? Games you can play right now with nothing
How to Play
- Read the case introduction aloud
- Consult the London Directory, map, and newspapers
- Decide which locations to visit as a team
- Read corresponding entries in the casebook
- Take notes on clues and testimony
- When ready, turn to questions section
- Answer questions about the case
- Compare your score to Sherlock's benchmark
- Each case is standalone and takes 1-3 hours
- 10 cases included per box set
Where to Buy
Find it on AmazonOpens an Amazon search for Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective. A purchase supports this site.
About This Game
The classic deduction game set in Victorian London. Read case introductions, visit locations across the city, interview witnesses, and try to solve the mystery with fewer leads than Holmes himself.
History & Background
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective originated in 1981, created by Consumnes Games (later Asmodee) as a revolutionary approach to tabletop gaming. The game transformed the detective genre by making players themselves the investigators, stepping into the shoes of Holmes's associates. Rather than a traditional board game with dice and tokens, it pioneered the narrative mystery format that would influence countless games over the following decades. The original concept was groundbreaking: using a casebook, map, and directory as primary game components created an immersive experience that felt more like solving an actual mystery than playing a structured game.
The game's cultural significance lies in its faithful adaptation of Arthur Conan Doyle's Victorian London setting and the challenge structure built around Sherlock Holmes's legendary deductive abilities. Players must solve cases in fewer moves than the master detective himself, creating an elegant competitive dynamic even in a cooperative format. The game captured the intellectual appeal of the Sherlock Holmes stories and translated them into interactive gameplay, proving that mysteries could be engaging gaming experiences without traditional mechanics.
Since its 1981 debut, Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective has undergone multiple reprints and expansions, with various case collections released over four decades. The game's longevity demonstrates its timeless appeal—the Victorian setting, logical puzzles, and collaborative problem-solving remain compelling for two players working together to outwit the game itself. Modern editions have refined the component quality while maintaining the original's elegant simplicity. Its influence on the mystery and narrative gaming genres has been substantial, inspiring numerous descendants and establishing the detective deduction game as a respected category within modern board gaming.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you play Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective with 2 players?
Yes! Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective is an excellent choice for 2 players — in fact, it's designed specifically for a duo. You'll get the full experience without any compromises.
How long does Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective take to play?
A typical game of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective takes about 60+ min. This can vary based on players' experience level and how quickly decisions are made.
What do you need to play Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective?
To play Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, you need: Casebook with case entries, London map, Newspapers, London Directory, and Pencil and paper.
Added 10 months ago. Updated 4 days ago. Browse more games
Similar Games
Want something different than Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective?
Answer 4 quick questions and we'll pick a game for tonight.
Sign in to rate this game